Bill Benson, with links to a transcription by Jason Fieler and detailed analysis by David Bruce, unpacks Jacob Collier’s fascinating harmonic shenanigans with “The Christmas Song.”
Category: Music
Wider
Or, how to confuse Spotify and YouTube’s algorithms (sorry, Molly!).
Well, a with a little extra time on my hands, I was able to complete Musicology Duck’s Listen Wider Challenge 2020 in only three months, much sooner than I expected. And two of the pieces I got to hear live (asterisks below).
The prompts:
- A composition of 60 minutes or more in length by a woman or non-binary composer
- *Kate Soper, Here Be Sirens (2014)
- A country song released in the last 6 months
- Ashley McBryde, “One Night Standards” (2019): I like this one a lot
- A chamber piece for 7-12 players written since 1980
- *George Lewis, Mnemosis (2012)
- The cast recording of a musical featuring a queer character
- Tim Acito and Alexander Dinelaris, Zanna, Don’t! (2003): “Fast” is a fun patter song
- A miniature composition under 90 seconds long
- Marc Shaiman and Scott Scott Wittman, “Twenty Seconds” (2020)
- An opera with a libretto by an author of color
- John Adams, June Jordan, I Was Looking at the Ceiling and Then I Saw the Sky (1995): I am an Adams fanboy, but this work is not successful. Tin-eared libretto, thin orchestration.
- A track by a Native/First Nations/Indigenous hip-hop artist
- Eekwol & T-Rhyme, “For Women By Women” (2018)
- A work by a student composer
- Tiara Tanka, “Bennu” (2015) for 3 flutes and cello: Tanka is a student in the Henry and Leigh Bienen School of Music, Northwestern University
- A work from a religious/spiritual tradition other than your own
- “Allah Hoo Allah Hoo,” Al-Haaj Muhammad Owais Raza Qadri
- A composition that won a major award in 2018 or 2019
- Kendrick Lamar, DAMN. (2017): “FEEL.” has whiffs of Bob Dylan, Gil Scott-Heron
- A classic rock album from the 1960s or 1970s you feel like you should have listened to in its entirety by now, but never have
- Traffic, Traffic (1968): left me unsatisfied; its two big songs do better as covers. After Blind Faith, Blind Faith (1969), I realized that a little Steve Winwood goes a long way. So I enjoyed Eric Clapton playing the blues on Cream, Disraeli Gears (1967).
- A piece by a composer from Central or South America
- Roque Cordero, “Sonatina Rítmica” (date?) and “Soliloquio” No.6 (1992)
- A campaign song for each of the opposing candidates in any election, current or historical
- Milton Ager and Jack Yellen, “Happy Days Are Here Again” (1929) vs. “Thank God! We’ve Found the Man” (1940): FDR vs. Willkie
- A composition written when the composer was older than age 80
- Milton Babbitt, “A Gloss on ‘Round Midnight” (2002): which sent me down the rabbit hole of Emanuele Arciuli, ‘Round Midnight: Homage to Thelonious Monk (2011)
- A piece notated using graphic notation
- Hans-Christoph Steiner, “Solitude” (2004)
- An instrumental work from before 1750 written by a woman
- Élisabeth Jacquet de La Guerre, Les pièces de clavessin, “Suite in D minor” (1687); and Elisabetta de Gambarini, Lessons for the Harpsichord, op. 2 (1748)
- A piece specifically for children by a composer or songwriter who usually writes for adults
- Imogen Heap, “The Happy Song” (2019)
- A top hit from the year you were born—from a country other than your own
- Peter Alexander, “Der Mond hält seine Wacht” (1956): wacky backing vocals. Also popular in Germany that year was “Sie heiß Mary Ann,” to the tune of Tennessee Ernie Ford’s “Sixteen Tons,” but nothing to do with coal mining.
- Two different tracks that sample the same song
- Run-D.M.C., “Run’s House”; and LL Cool J, “The Boomin’ System”: I did not know about James Brown’s “The Funky Drummer.”
- A song sung by two or more siblings
- Fred and Adele Astaire, “Fascinating Rhythm” (1924)
- The soundtrack for a film in a language other than English
- Yann Tiersen, Le fabuleux destin d’Amélie Poulain (2001)
- An art music composition (broadly defined) that received its premiere in an African country
- Bongani Ndodana-Breen, Three Orchestral Songs on poems by Ingrid Jonker (2015)
- A classical recording from an independent label
- Aheym (2013) ANTI187296-2, Kronos Quartet plays music of Bryce Dessner
- A record by a winning Eurovision Song Contest performer other than their competition song
- Netta, “BEG” and “Nana Banana”
- A protest song by a songwriter who identifies as LGBTQIA+
- “We Stand United” (2016)
- A song or piece written to memorialize victims of a natural disaster
- Tom Rush, “Galveston Flood” (1966)
- A song by an artist currently atop Billboard’s “Social 50” chart
- BTS, “Black Swan” (2020)
- A concerto for tuba, bassoon, or double bass
- Johann Nepomuk Hummel, concerto in F for bassoon (ca. 1805), Mathis Kaspar Stier (bassoon)
- A jazz album recorded since 2015
- Ezra Weiss Big Band, We Limit Not the Truth of God (2019)
- A song written by or from the perspective of an immigrant
- Alexis Torres Machado, “For My Immigrants” (2016)
Mind you, I came by a couple of the recordings via the CD giveaway shelf at work.
Peculiar muzak: 6
A syrupy, overwrought arrangement for string orchestra of “Friends,” by Elton John and Bernie Taupin, in the corridors of my doc’s medical building.
Check back in December
I’m going to try Musicology Duck’s Listen Wider Challenge 2020:
Listen to:
- A composition of 60 minutes or more in length by a woman or non-binary composer
- A country song released in the last 6 months
- A chamber piece for 7-12 players written since 1980
- The cast recording of a musical featuring a queer character
- A miniature composition under 90 seconds long
- An opera with a libretto by an author of color
- A track by a Native/First Nations/Indigenous hip-hop artist
- A work by a student composer
- A work from a religious/spiritual tradition other than your own
- A composition that won a major award in 2018 or 2019
- A classic rock album from the 1960s or 1970s you feel like you should have listened to in its entirety by now, but never have
- A piece by a composer from Central or South America
- A campaign song for each of the opposing candidates in any election, current or historical
- A composition written when the composer was older than age 80
- A piece notated using graphic notation
- An instrumental work from before 1750 written by a woman
- A piece specifically for children by a composer or songwriter who usually writes for adults
- A top hit from the year you were born—from a country other than your own
- Two different tracks that sample the same song
- A song sung by two or more siblings
- The soundtrack for a film in a language other than English
- An art music composition (broadly defined) that received its premiere in an African country
- A classical recording from an independent label
- A record by a winning Eurovision Song Contest performer other than their competition song
- A protest song by a songwriter who identifies as LGBTQIA+
- A song or piece written to memorialize victims of a natural disaster
- A song by an artist currently atop Billboard’s “Social 50” chart
- A concerto for tuba, bassoon, or double bass
- A jazz album recorded since 2015
- A song written by or from the perspective of an immigrant
Some of these will be easier than others to find, among them #29, #11, and especially #19, if I count the Amen Break.
Don’t ask Eliot
A jewel of a simile in Alex Ross’s survey of composer and performer Tyshawn Sorey:
Anyone who worries whether Sorey has the chops to create “normal” music can sample “Movement,” on Alloy, which opens with a ravishingly melancholy piano solo in F-sharp minor. It’s a bit like Alban Berg playing piano in a hotel lounge at the end of the world.
Red lithium grease
Debugging the set for the Met’s Ring production.
When the giant planks spun into new positions — moving swiftly, say, to transform from the forest where the young hero Siegmund is being hunted to the fateful house where he seeks shelter — a whooshing sound could sometimes be heard. Officials dubbed it the “rainstick effect.”
Waxy
What’s it like to record an aria on 120-year-old technology? Met tenor Piotr Beczala and soprano Susanna Phillips give it a try.
Angular
Cecil Taylor’s passing reminds me of my favorite passage from Craig Lucas, from scene 2 of Blue Window. It’s a good thing that I have a printed copy to refer to, because my recollection of the dialogue, from a production I saw 22 years ago, is faulty.
At a small gathering/party of friends, Tom has put a recording of Cecil Taylor on the sound system.
TOM. But I don’t know if you can hear it, but I mean, he’s literally rethinking what you can do with melody. He’s changing all the rules from the ground up.
* * *
TOM. Like a painter. He’s breaking it up, you know, and putting some parts of it in front of where they belong and he’s splitting up tonalities and colors, shapes —
ALICE. Splitting up did you say?
TOM. Splitting.
ALICE. No, I know, I was…
TOM. He’s literally challenging you to hear it, you know, rehear it. What is music?
GRIEVER. No, I know, but this isn’t like a famous melody? Or –?
TOM. Why not?
GRIEVER. I mean it isn’t like “Raindrops on roses and whiskers on kittens” backwards or something.
TOM. No…
For some reason I always want to remember that as “‘Mairzy Doats’ upside down and backwards.”
Squeeze Waves REM
All the more difficult in my case, since at the present time I have boxes of mix tapes for two: “Party like it’s 1989: What should you do with all those old cassette mix tapes?”, by John Kelly.
Peculiar muzak: 5
A lush, ostinato-less “Every Breath You Take,” in the lobby of Navy Federal Credit Union, Reston branch.
Peculiar muzak: 4
Portishead, “Sour Times,” in the Unique thrift store in Merrifield.
Clybourne Park: an update: 2
So we closed the show yesterday afternoon, and I’m pleased, overall, with the way it went. (There’s always something that you wish could have been better. Like I wish that I’d had a coach to help me fine-tune the brief bit of stage combat.)
Every so often I use music as a way to get into the world of a character. (My friend Lisa suggested this trick a long time ago.) Now, the little Bobby McFerrin riff that Roger used as transition music at the top of Act 2 was all I needed to help me find Tom Driscoll. But for the well-meaning, somewhat feckless, gentle parish priest Rev. Jim in Act 1, I needed a complete playlist. Some of this music I already had on hand, and some was newly-purchased. Here it is, Jim’s Jam, all songs pre-1959 as far as I can tell:
- Perry Como, “Accentuate the Positive”
- Lawrence Welk orchestra, “Bubbles in the Wine”
- Patsy Cline, “Walkin’ after Midnight”
- Glenn Miller orchestra, “(I’ve Got a Gal in) Kalamazoo”
- Mel Tormé, “Moonlight in Vermont”
- Lawrence Welk orchestra, “Beer Barrel Polka”
- Perry Como, “May the Good Lord Bless and Keep You”
- Mantovani orchestra, “Charmaine”
- Patti Page, “Old Cape Cod”
- Glenn Miller orchestra, “A String of Pearls”
- Perry Como, “He’s Got the Whole World in His Hands”
- Lawrence Welk orchestra, “Village Tavern Polka”
Mantovani’s version of a 1926 waltz by Rapée and Pollack is most everyone’s idea of soul-evacuating elevator music. (I remember an ironic modern dance troupe performance from about 20 years ago, set on this song, that consisted of the entire company queueing up as if at the DMV.) But for Jim, the lush, pillowy arrangement is pure bliss, his idea of what God’s grace must feel like. Is that a zither in the mix in the last chords? Plus, you can do t’ai chi stretches to it.
Jim and Judy danced to Glenn Miller when they were courting.
The Lawrence Welk recordings, all from the pre-TV days, are astonishing. Joyful, energetic, inventive, not slick at all—nothing like the bland music I heard when I was a kid in my grandfather’s living room watching the TV show. I used to worry that I was turning into my mother. Now I should worry that I’m turning into her father.
How does it feel
To sweeten a Blue Saturday, Orkestra Obsolete plays New Order’s “Blue Monday” using only instruments and technology available in the 1930s.
ᔥ kottke.org and @tcarmody
Composure
Craig Havighurst has proposed a new umbrella term for that thing that most people call classical music, that my friends in college (particularly in the School of Music) encouraged me to call art music or serious music, and that I have also heard described as Western concert hall music. Havighust likes the term composed music, and he makes some good points.
Composed Music’s primary virtue is its blunt veracity. It is what it says it is: works by a singular mind, fixed and promulgated in written form. …it emphasizes the actual creator of the music, giving credit where it’s due in an era when the general public has been conditioned to associate works with performers.
And lest we forget,
The awkwardness of there being a Classical Period in Classical Music becomes moot.
In a follow-up, he points out that he intends the term to include jazz and third stream compositions as well, written by artists as diverse as Brubeck and Zappa.
Of course, we can always go with the dichotomy associated with Edward Kennedy “Duke” Ellington:
There are simply two kinds of music, good music and the other kind.
That sound you hear is my head exploding
Chris Ware, Ira Glass, Nico Muhly, and John Kuramoto, d.b.a. “Phoobis,” create an animated cover for this week’s issue of The New Yorker. Guest-starring a former Secretary of State.